Y Axis Not showing Values

First metric shows a value in the Y axis, placement is auto and is on the left. I add a second metric and it plots the value, I can see the line on the graph but this metric is not displaying a Y axis value. It doesn’t change if I override to say put it on the right, change it’s unit value, etc.

It’s like a master setting somewhere telling it to only show a single Y axis value.

How to change?